Bar Soap

Handcrafted Bar Soap — Artisan Soap Bars Made in Monticello, FL

Slip into the simple luxury of a truly handmade bar of soap. Our artisan bar soap is small-batch crafted in our Monticello, Florida workshop with creamy shea butter, nourishing oils, and rich, true-to-life fragrance — the kind of soap that turns a daily shower into a quiet ritual.

What You’ll Find in Our Bar Soap Collection

Over 100 handcrafted soaps, including crowd favorites like Black Raspberry Vanilla, Kentucky Bourbon, Vanilla Bean, Tobacco & Bay Leaf, Pink Grapefruit, Citrus Trifecta, Marigold & Melon, and our signature Monticello Watermelon Festival bar. Looking for something specific? Explore our goat milk bar soap, tallow bar soap, men’s soaps, face & body bars, and citrus soaps like Squeeze the Day Lemon and Zest of Lime.

Why Customers Love Our Handmade Soap Bars

  • Real shea butter & nourishing oils — a creamy, conditioning lather that doesn’t leave skin tight.
  • Natural fragrance, true to scent — from bright citrus and warm vanilla to herbal, woodsy, and floral profiles.
  • Vegetarian and paraben-free — clean ingredients you can read and pronounce.
  • Handcrafted in Monticello, Florida — cut, cured, and packaged by us, never outsourced.

Pair your favorite bar with a soap saver bag or wooden soap dish to make it last, or build a gift with our ready-made gift sets.

59 products

Monticello Watermelon Festival handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, pink and green watermelon-inspired bar.
Pink Strawberry handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, vibrant pink bar with sugared strawberry and vanilla notes.
Monticello Limoncello handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, bright yellow lemon-scented bar with whimsical lemon embed.
Mango Coconut goat milk massage bar by Monticello Soap Company, tropical melt-and-pour bar with built-in massage nubs.
Marigold & Melon handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, garden-fresh bar with melon and marigold notes.
Pink Grapefruit handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, blush rose clay bar with grapefruit essential oil.
Citrus Jewelweed handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, a dark bar with jewelweed, pine tar, and charcoal.
Rustic Mango and Coconut Milk handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, golden turmeric-tinted tropical bar.
Squeeze the Day Lemon handcrafted soap by Monticello Soap Company, novelty bar shaped like a real lemon.

Squeeze the Day Lemon Soap
$5.00
Zest of Lime handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, novelty bar shaped like a fresh lime with crisp citrus scent.
Hibiscus & Honey Red Reef Clay handcrafted face and body bar by Monticello Soap Company, blush clay bar with floral honey notes.
Kentucky Bourbon handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, layered with natural blue indigo and bourbon notes of oak, leather, and orchid.
Best Seller
Just Tea Tree handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, crisp herbal tea tree essential oil bar with kaolin clay.
Vanilla Bean handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, creamy warm vanilla bar with gentle poppy seed exfoliation.
Tobacco and Bay Leaf handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, warm earthy bar with cedarwood, bergamot, and tobacco notes.
Dr Pine pine tar handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, dark rugged bar with charcoal, oatmeal, and sea clay.
Black Raspberry Vanilla handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, indigo and berry red swirl with vanilla, plum wine, and orchid notes.
Midnight Waters with Gold handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, deep blue oceanic bar with charcoal and gold shimmer top.
Lavender Lullaby handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, soothing lavender bar with mica shimmer for evening wind-down.
Barn & Butter handcrafted tallow goat milk bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, unscented family-friendly bar.
Blackberry & Sage handcrafted tallow bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, juicy blackberry and fresh sage scent.
Cherry Almond handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, sweet cherry and warm almond comfort bar.
Hickory and Suede handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, refined men's shaving bar with leather, cypress, and sandalwood.
Coffee Shop handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, dark exfoliating bar with real coffee grounds and brewed coffee scent.
1 2 3 Next »