Bar Soap

Handcrafted Bar Soap — Artisan Soap Bars Made in Monticello, FL

Slip into the simple luxury of a truly handmade bar of soap. Our artisan bar soap is small-batch crafted in our Monticello, Florida workshop with creamy shea butter, nourishing oils, and rich, true-to-life fragrance — the kind of soap that turns a daily shower into a quiet ritual.

What You’ll Find in Our Bar Soap Collection

Over 100 handcrafted soaps, including crowd favorites like Black Raspberry Vanilla, Kentucky Bourbon, Vanilla Bean, Tobacco & Bay Leaf, Pink Grapefruit, Citrus Trifecta, Marigold & Melon, and our signature Monticello Watermelon Festival bar. Looking for something specific? Explore our goat milk bar soap, tallow bar soap, men’s soaps, face & body bars, and citrus soaps like Squeeze the Day Lemon and Zest of Lime.

Why Customers Love Our Handmade Soap Bars

  • Real shea butter & nourishing oils — a creamy, conditioning lather that doesn’t leave skin tight.
  • Natural fragrance, true to scent — from bright citrus and warm vanilla to herbal, woodsy, and floral profiles.
  • Vegetarian and paraben-free — clean ingredients you can read and pronounce.
  • Handcrafted in Monticello, Florida — cut, cured, and packaged by us, never outsourced.

Pair your favorite bar with a soap saver bag or wooden soap dish to make it last, or build a gift with our ready-made gift sets.

59 products

Drunken Goat handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, Scotch whiskey scented goat milk bar with blue indigo design.

Drunken Goat - Bar Soap
$8.00
Ducky Soap handcrafted novelty bar by Monticello Soap Company, melt-and-pour bar topped with rubber duck.

Ducky Soap
$5.00
Elsie handcrafted tallow and goat milk bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, gentle classic bar with shea butter.
Goat Milk Castile Baby Bar handcrafted by Monticello Soap Company, unscented gentle Castile bar for newborn and sensitive skin.
Goat Milk Orange Cedarwood handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, creamy goat milk bar with citrus and woody essential oils.
Hickory Goat Face & Body handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, warm hickory goat milk bar for daily face and body care.
Hunter's Soap unscented handcrafted bar by Monticello Soap Company, fragrance-free charcoal bar with shea butter for outdoor use.
Lava handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, bright citrus tropical bar with eco glitter and mica swirl.
Lavender Driftwood handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, calming cold-process bar with lavender and warm woody notes.
Monstera Mist handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, monstera leaf-shaped novelty bar with sage and lemongrass scent.
Olive Wood and Cypress handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, mint green and peach swirl with earthy cypress and olive wood notes.
Rocco's Rhythm Castile-style handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, unscented gentle bar for sensitive skin.
Rose Clay Face Soap handcrafted by Monticello Soap Company, unscented rose clay bar for daily face care.

Rose Clay Face Soap
$8.00
Sea Glass handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, coastal-inspired bar with ocean mist scent and tumbled glass look.
Sea Minerals handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, coastal calm bar with ocean mist and driftwood notes.
Simply Succulent handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, succulent-shaped novelty bar with soft linen scent.
Soap Surprise mystery mini bar bag by Monticello Soap Company, zero-waste assortment of small handcrafted soap bars.
Spotted Goat handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, goat milk and local honey bar with kaolin clay.
Velvet Ember Face Soap handcrafted by Monticello Soap Company, warm men's face bar with vanilla, sandalwood, and brut notes.
Woody Goat Milk handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, cedarwood and sweet orange essential oil bar.
Pink Berry Parfait handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, layered pink and cream parfait-style bar with sweet berry scent.
Very Berry handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, cream and pink swirl bar with fresh-picked berry scent.

Very Berry - Bar Soap
$8.00
Bay Rum Face & Body Bar handcrafted by Monticello Soap Company, charcoal-detail bar with classic warm bay rum scent.
Apple Bourbon handcrafted bar soap by Monticello Soap Company, autumn-inspired bar with apple, bourbon, ginger, and caramel notes.
« Previous 1 2 3 Next »